The Burning of Cherry Hill [resubmit]

The author says:

THE BURNING OF CHERRY HILL is a dystopian novel set in North America 150 years in the future. Though it features teenage protagonists, it was written for the older teen/adult crowd. The siblings (Zay, 14, and Lina, 12) grew up on an island in hiding from a government they never knew existed. They are remanded to foster care when said government brutally kidnaps their fugitive parents and burns down their home. The kids have to learn to cope with a totalitarian (but prosperous and outwardly generous) government while trying to figure out a way to find and rescue their parents. The tulip is a recurring literary theme in the story.

image

image

[original submission and comments here]

Nathan says:

I.
Love.
It.

The color scheme bullseyes the dystopian vibe, the typography is clear, and the tulip motif is present but unobtrusive.

The only solid suggestion I’d give is to put periods after the initials in the byline, because there are so many series books out there that are “A Something-Something Book” that a reader could initially assume that the “A” is the word, not an initial.

If I were doing the design, I’d probably experiment with things like adding a very subtle “grunge” texture to the type, or reducing “The” and “of” in the title, but I don’t know that I’d decide in favor of either.

Well done.

Anyone say different? (If you do, you’ll have to answer to ME!)

Our Love’s Irreversibility

The author says:

(Note to Mr. Shumate: I hope you’ll pardon the verbosity; this is a fantastically complicated story. Also, this is a *very* preliminary “scratch” cover: I haven’t finished writing the last third of the novel yet, and I’m considering hiring a professional artist to do the actual final cover.) Truth can be stranger than fiction, as Don Richards knows: his unlikely modern fairytale marriage with Denise, the unwed teen mother he hired to take care of his little son Jackie after his first wife died in a car wreck, has Don doubting his life can possibly get any more bizarre, even with their Carribean honeymoon cruise passing through the legendary Bermuda Triangle. Fiction, however, proves to have a few surprises of its own as the Bermuda Triangle proves to be a place in which paranormal events long dismissed as exaggerations and mythical mumbo-jumbo are rare, but do happen. The trouble is, when myths come true in reality, metaphor is powerless to dispel these paranormal events the way it does in all the made-up stories. In Mr. and Mrs. Richards’ case, this is especially problematic because their minds have also been swapped with those of his nine-year-old son Jackie and her eight-and-a-half-year-old daughter Jaymee, respectively. What will they do if their swap proves to be irreversible? This is an adult paranormal romance with just a hint of time travel and a kind of “trash TV talk show meets the Brady Bunch meets Freaky Friday meets John Varley’s ‘Air Raid'” plot to it.

Our Love's Irreversibility Scratch Cover

Our Love's Irreversibility Scratch CoverNathan says:

(I hope the author doesn’t mind that I included his note to me in his description above, as I think it contains important information.)

Your cover ideas have good elements. I always encourage going with a professional, but the following may be helpful if you either decide to go it alone or want to give the designer other ideas:

1) Is your byline really “Blake Rem Lumen Coryn”?  That may be your name, but I think it’s ungainly as a byline — there’s distinctive (e.g., Martin Smith adding his “Cruz” middle name to stand out), but then there’s unwieldy.  People are unused to author names that are more than three names long — it doesn’t look like a name at first glance. I think “Blake Coryn” is distinctive enough to stick in memory much better than a four-part name would. (Also, once your name looks like a name, the  “By” is unnecessary.)

2) There’s a lot of unused background space. Especially when you look at it at thumbnail size, you can see that the large areas of nothing-but-rail to left and right add nothing.  You can make the child silhouettes larger and thus more immediately recognizable.

3) One of my rules of thumb is “big words need simple fonts.”  Irreversibility (which my spellchecker isn’t even recognizing as a word) is a perfect example. As you can see especially in the thumbnail, the word easily turns into “bunch of letter that cause me to tune out.” Also, the gradient in both the title and byline reduces the contrast and thus the readability.

4) There’s such a thing as having too many things aligned to the center. Shifting the moon off to one side (my instinct says to the left, but I can’t back that up) adds a little bit of variety to the layout.

Other ideas?

 

First Steps [resubmit]

The editor says:

Each story was written to the the theme of “A short fiction piece between 800 and 5000 words, in which the main character is traveling, either in flight or on a journey of self-discovery.” This book is the first anthology of short fiction by members of the Madrid Writers Club in Spain. Thank you for the feedback. This redesign addresses most of the issues well, I hope.

FirstStepsMadridWritersClub

FirstStepsMadridWritersClub

[original submission and comments here]

Nathan says:

Making the title more readable is definitely a good thing. And I like what you’ve done with varying the type size on the two other blocks of text.

I still think you ought to have a subtitle that indicates the common theme, unless you’re planning on only selling to friends and family who would buy it whatever the subject matter is.

 

The Arctic Deception

The author says:

In the Arctic for a mundane protection detail after a failed rescue mission in Afghanistan, US Army Sergeant Kieran Blackwell and his elite Special Forces unit known as the Dragon Taskforce are looking forward to the quiet. But when a group of highly trained commandos attack the research facility and kill one of the scientists they’re protecting, Blackwell and his team discover that the “real” research being conducted has nothing to do with the effects of global warming, but something much more sinister. Blackwell and his team must use all of their skills to fend off the enemy and escape from the hellish Arctic landscape alive.

Arctic-Deception

Arctic-DeceptionNathan says:

A lot of good elements here, and the dragon image is both simple and striking.

My concerns lie almost exclusively with the type. As someone with a similarly uncommon name, I’ve found that the more unusual your name is, the more clearly you have to render it on the cover to make it readable. If the you’re using has lowercase characters, try using them at least for your surname; if not, I’d seriously consider using another font.

Also, the way the title is scrunched at the bottom makes it look like it’s an afterthought and you don’t want to cover up any of the cover art — which is striking and all, but not so amazing that you should feel bad about intruding on it. I’d let the title and subtitle take up the area at least to the dragon’s knee.

Other suggestions?

 

Family of Fortune

The author says:

An orphan is adopted by pirates and goes on a search for her birth parents through 17th century London.

newfof

newfof

 

Nathan says:

You didn’t say, but I’m assuming you’re going for a middle-grade audience. Yes?

I think the sketchy line art can work, but the color work is just a little too blunt and rushed-looking for me. (Is there any way we could add some clue of gender to the pirate-girl?)

There’s no reason that the title can’t stretch to the left, over the netting. Make it larger and more visible!

Anyone else?