The author says:

Set in Boston current day timing, Contemporary Romance. readers: women 20-65 age group. This would be directed at the same kind of audience as Nicholas Sparks, Romance but giving attention to other issues such as adoption, etc.

Young woman of 18, meeting and falling in love with medical resident of 23. As a baby she was adopted, but due to circumstances, reunited with her biological father early in the series. She has gone through reunification with biological mother and other serious issues such as anxiety etc, again earlier in the series.

Nathan says:

Given that this is fifth of a series, I looked up the previous books to check the branding (here, here, here and here), and with that in mind, this book looks like you’re bullseyeing the branding perfectly. I don’t think there’s anything you need to change on the front. (The back looks pretty wordy to me — I’d be more comfortable with half as much text.)

Now, if you’re ever looking for changes across the entire series, I’d experiment with pushing everything just a little lighter, just a little warmer/pinker.

Other comments?

The author says:

She thought he was neurotic. He thought she was psychotic.

The Navy thought they were the perfect pair. Shelby Ryder is a loose cannon. A Kansas farm girl, she became a Navy SEAL to avenge her parents, who were killed on vacation when a Russian sub torpedoed their catamaran. Earl Bernstein, from Chicago, became a SEAL to get away from his over-protective parents. Earl’s the sensitive type. He writes poetry and worries about his teeth enamel eroding. The Navy thought by pairing them together they would balance each other out. They were wrong. After brushes with the law and staying just this side of sanity, Shelby and Earl are on the verge of being de-SEALed. Now they’ve been given one last chance to redeem themselves. It’s a simple enough mission: they’re tasked with finding a United States senator who disappeared in Cuba while playing golf. But then one day the president tweets that the Russians are responsible, and things get hairy in a hurry. Soon it becomes clear—if Shelby and Earl don’t get the senator back, the situation will escalate into a nuclear war. So into the steamy Cuban jungles filled with snakes, spies and a German tuba band, the pair ventures, breaking every rule of civilized behavior known to man as they desperately try to find the senator before the missiles fly or Earl runs out of anti-cavity rinse.

This is what I would like to think is a final image. It’s not a quick concept demo. Set in Cuba now.

genre: humorous thriller

target audience: people who like over-the-top humor

similar authors: Carl Hiaasen, Tim Dorsey

Nathan says:

Hmm. Something about it says “memoir” or something similar to me.  The title and tagline point to comedy, but the graphic elements don’t convey humor (which is tough to do).

I took a look at covers by the authors you mention, Carl Hiassen and Tim Dorsey:

I can see where you drew on them for inspiration, but I think you missed the part that conveys humor. The images on the majority of covers from both authors are more than a little cartoony, and the majority of the fonts are either more chaotic than yours (which could be solved by shifting the letter positions, etc.) or more whimsical.

I think you’re on the right track.  You just need to bring the funny.

Other comments?

The author says:

 Following the advice of some commenters (thank you to all who the took the time, it really helped!) I went back to the drawing board and redid both covers for my series. I think the backgrounds work, but I’m having some trouble with the text and how to set it off a bit more. Maybe a color overlay on the text? Maybe I don’t need to? I’m trying to keep things a bit more simple but I may have gone too far. I am also unsure on the font itself. A more bold, less disintegrating font, may be better and simpler.

Genre: Cyberpunk, Sci-fi.

Elevator pitch: In the second novella, a night of playing a VRMMORPG turns dark when one of Ragan’s friends doesn’t wake up after being captured by a raid boss. Using her skills as computer security cracker she will have to figure out what is trapping people in the game, and for what reason before time runs out.

First cover redone: https://imgur.com/a/Onqw2mI

[original submission and comments here]

Nathan says:

It’s definitely a much bolder concept for a cover. With some tweaks, I think it’ll be perfect.

I think the main problem with the title font isn’t so much the distress, it’s the proportion.  With a long word like “FUNCTION” displayed vertically, it ends up being confined to the far left (in contrast to the redone first cover, where the vertical “DATA” dominates nicely).  I would try stretching the font horizontally by maybe 20%, and see if that gives it the visual weight you need.

As far as making the title pop from the background, I think the solution is simple: darken the background and use pure white for the type instead of off-white.

Other comments?